Group calls later publication of Rail Baltic survey findings "a disappointment"

The postponement of the disclosure of the findings of the feasibility study of Rail Baltic is a disappointment and the published summary fails to answer the question of whether building the railway is justified, an Estonian pressure group, Avalikult Rail Balticust, said on Monday.


"Waiting for the new feasibility study, the government should not limit itself to the individual numbers published so far. It's important to look at the numbers: what are the risks and based on what presumptions and using what models these predictions were made," Priit Humal, spokesman for Avalikult Rail Balticust, said in a press release.

"After the publication of the survey done by AECOM the government made a decision based on it a little less than four months after it was published. This was actually too short a time because an independent audit should have been made of the analysis, which was never done," Humal said.

"According to the summary published today, the analysis fails to answer the question of whether RB in the planned form is the best solution. The feasibility analysis also fails to answer the question of whether the railway should be built in the planned form at all."

The nonprofit pointed out that with an EU cofinancing rate of 85 percent, Estonia would have to pay 268 million euros of the project's total cost of 5.8 billion euros, Latvia 393 million and Lithuania 493 million euros. According to EY, the project's total socio-economic benefit for the Baltic countries would amount to 16.2 billion euros.

"According to the new feasibility study, Rail Baltic needs 4.6 billion euros from the European Union, which is almost double the amount suggested by AECOM," the NPO said, referring to the AECOM estimate of 2.4 billion euros. A precondition for that estimate is a continued 85 percent cofinancing rate, which nobody can guarantee at this point. Baiba Rubesa, CEO of RB Rail AS, did not give a concrete answer to the question of how is the RB project planned to continue if the desired amount of money from the EU doesn't come or comes with a lower cofinancing rate," Avalikult Rail Balticust said.

Freshly published results of a cost-benefit analysis carried out by Ernst & Young (EY), which will not be disclosed in full for now, show that the Rail Baltic project is financially feasible and the project would need additional financial support in the first five years as well as start from 2048 when bigger infrastructure upgrades are needed.

The joint venture of the three Baltic countries, RB Rail AS, has decided not to disclose the study at the moment but is planning to publish its extended summary in the next few weeks.

baltictimes
RailBaltic Ernst&Young AECOM
If you notice an error, highlight the text you want and press Ctrl + Enter to report it to the editor
2 views in december
I recommend
No recommendations yet

Comments

Post your comment to communicate and discuss this article.

Society
At the Riigikogu sitting beginning at 10:00 EET on Tuesday, Prime Minister Jüri Ratas (Centre) will provide an overview of the activities of the Estonian government in the implementation of EU policies. Chairman of the European Union Affairs Committee of the Riigikogu Toomas Vitsut (Centre) will also deliver a report, and representatives of the Riigikogu's parliamentary groups will present their positions, according to a Riigikogu press release. In his rep...
Society
Chairman of the opposition Conservative People's Party of Estonia (EKRE) Mart Helme has called on Helir-Valdor Seeder, chairman of junior coalition member Pro Patria to tie the latter's support for the state budget bill to a decision by the government not to support joining the UN Global Compact on Migration. "Pro Patria still has the chance to demand from its coalition partners [the Center Party and the Social Democratic Party (SDE)] that its stances be t...
Society
Political news portal Politico published its list of the most influential people in Europe next year last week, with fifth place going to Estonia’s cybersecurity ambassador Heli Tiirmaa-Klaar. Tiirmaa-Klaar takes her place in between well-known Europeans, after Secretary General of the European Commission Martin Selmayr and in front of Ukrainian presidential hopeful Yulia Tymoshenko. Politico believes Italy’s populist interior minister Matteo Salvini will...
Society
Representatives of the transport ministries of the Baltic states, Finland and Poland who met in Tallinn on Monday were of differing opinions regarding whether to remain in summer or winter time once the practice of changing the clocks twice per year comes to an end. A recent survey indicates that more than half of Estonians would prefer permanent summer time. Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Finland and Poland jointly acknowledged that the agreement to end the...
Society
Ida-Viru Central Hospital is having trouble with patients not showing up to scheduled specialist appointments. To combat this issue, beginning next year, the hospital will start charging visit fees for no-show appointments as well. Last year, patients at Ida-Viru Central Hospital failed to show up for scheduled appointments a total of nearly 9,500 times, accounting for some 5% of all hospital visits, reported ETV news broadcast Aktuaalne kaamera. "Patients...
Society
Tallinn city government finds that it is not reasonable to relocate the Tallinn Bus Station to the Ülemiste district near Tallinn Airport and that it should be left in its current location on Lastekodu Street. In connection with the preparation of an architectural idea competition and the drawing up of a detailed plan for the Ülemiste terminal in the framework of the Rail Baltic railway project, the city is drawing the attention of the Ministry of Economic...
Society
A criminal investigation has been launched into the Medita Clinic, one of the largest private sector bidders in public procurement tenders in the health sector in Estonia. The Northern District Prosecutor's Office initiated the investigation in accordance with the Penal Code section concerning the transmission of false information, according to ETV investigative show Pealtnägija. The Medita Clinic was the largest private provider of specialist medical care...
Society
The Tax and Customs Board (MTA) has signed an agreement with Online accommodation and hospitality marketplace Airbnb which enables hosts to automatically report earnings. The MTA and Airbnb held a joint press conference on Wednesday, announcing the agreement's signing as well as the new system and its rationale. The main premise, according to MTA deputy director Rivo Reitmann, is to keep things simple, meaning that Airbnb hosts who declare their income in...
Society
Luminor notified its clients that as of 1 January, the bank will be closing the accounts of Estonian e-residents that fail to fulfil due diligence. Hannes Oja, head of Anti-Money Laundering at Luminor Estonia, said that based on the Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing Prevention Act, banks are required to update the data of all of their customers, writes daily Eesti Päevaleht (EPL). As a result, all existing clients have to do so themselves on a regul...