Child pornography case against writer continues after prosecutor's appeal

Charged with the creation and distribution of child pornography in 2016, writer Kaur Kender was acquitted by the Harju County Court in May. After prosecutor Lea Pähkel appealed the first-tier court decision, hearings now continue in the Tallinn Circuit Court.

The Harju County Court acquitted Kender in May quoting the fact that all of the experts who were questioned and that had issued written opinions agreed that Kender's short story “Untitled 12” was not pornographic, as it lacked the features of pornography - writes err.ee.

First-tier court: Kender’s work is art

The experts found that Kender’s short story qualified as transgressive literature and did have literary and artistic value, the court noted. As his work depicted fictional characters, it was art, and in its form literature. “A fictional character does not have fundamental rights, and the character cannot be addressed as a person with legal capacity,” the court confirmed.

The court also noted that the artistic freedom set out in the Constitution could only be restricted in order to avert threats to the fundamental rights of actually existing people.

The court also ordered the state to pay €20,028 for Kender’s legal fees, €35,666 for expert evaluations, and €500 in compensation for non-patrimonial damage as well as slightly over €5,000 for other expert appraisal fees.

Prosecutor Lea Pähkel appealed the decision, and on Wednesday the matter was taken up by the Tallinn Circuit Court. In the first hearing, Pähkel said that the artistic value of Kender’s work did not matter in the case at hand, and continued on her original line of child pornography accusations.

Pähkel is also contesting the Harju County Court’s ruling that the state should pay damages to Kender and cover his legal and expert fees.

Kaur Kender: The world's most diseased place for the Estonian language

Prosecutor: Art doesn’t enter into it

The prosecutor argued that the previous-tier court introduced inappropriate conditions to the evaluation of Kender’s short story. These included the argument that for a case against the writer to hold up, the children affected would need to exist in actual fact, that the work would need to be seen as potentially arousing to a pedophile, that it would need to be of artistic value, and that the work would need to have the aim to elicit disgust, and overwhelm the reader.

“The Penal Code doesn’t specify the aim of a piece of pornography, and doesn’t demand an assessment of what it contains, for example in terms of its potential to arouse pedophiles,” Pähkel said, adding that the story still described sexual acts involving children in a vulgar and intrusive way, and that in the light of this fact the Estonian Penal Code didn’t call for an assessment of the text in question to define whether or not it was literature or art.

Pähkel pointed out that child pornography depicted in photographs and videos wasn’t assessed for its artistic value either. From the point of view of establishing guilt, neither the objective of the creation of the material at hand nor the objectives of owning and distributing it mattered.

The requirement in the Harju County Court’s reasoning that the children in the case would need to exist in reality for a case against Kender to hold didn’t matter either, Pähkel said. According to § 178 of the Estonian Penal Code, any depiction of a child in a pornographic situation was illegal.

In addition to the Penal Code, the prosecutor based her line of argument on the United Nations’ Convention on the Rights of the Child as well as the European Union’s provisions for the protection of children from sexual abuse. These clearly defined child pornography as a so-called “world crime” against which all of civilized society needed to take action, Pähkel said.

Following Penal Code to the letter would go against Constitution, court argues

The question is whether the courts should follow the Penal Code to the letter, or in making their judgment also consider the purpose of the corresponding paragraph of the Penal Code. The first-tier court’s reasoning followed the idea that in order for § 178 to be applied purposefully, there would need to be specific and actually existing children in need of protection, and that seeing as Kender’s work was fictitious, this wasn’t the case.

Pähkel’s argument, on the other hand, follows the exact words in § 178, which say that the “Manufacture, acquisition or storing, handing over, displaying or making available to another person in any other manner of pictures, writings or other works or reproductions of works depicting a person of less than eighteen years of age in a pornographic situation, or a person of less than fourteen years of age in a pornographic or erotic situation, is punishable by a pecuniary punishment or up to three years’ imprisonment”.

The first-tier court rejected this as well, as the literal application of the paragraph would go against § 45 of the Constitution:

Everyone has the right to freely disseminate ideas, opinions, beliefs and other information by word, print, picture or other means. This right may be circumscribed by law to protect public order, public morality, and the rights and freedoms, health, honour and good name of others. This right may also be circumscribed by law in respect of public servants employed by the national government and local authorities, or in order to protect a state secret, trade secret or information received in confidence which has become known to the public servant by reason of his or her office, and to protect the family and private life of others, as well as in the interests of the administration of justice.

There is no censorship.

The Tallinn Circuit Court will make its decision in Kender’s case on Nov. 11 this year.

Read more news of Tallinn on our site.

err.ee
child_pornography_case writer Etonian
If you notice an error, highlight the text you want and press Ctrl + Enter to report it to the editor
I recommend
No recommendations yet

Comments

Post your comment to communicate and discuss this article.

Politics
Chairman of the Estonian Chamber of Commerce and Industry and one of the owners of construction group Nordecon, Toomas Luman, finds that a prime ministerial candidate should first and foremost be able to answer the question of what will become of the demographic crisis in Estonia. The businessman sees controlled introduction of foreign labor as the solution. A digital construction cluster was created in Estonia a few years back to bring innovation to the s...
Society
Last year saw 27,125 registered offenses, up 0.5 percent from the year before. Violent crime was up by 12 percent to 8,249 offenses. PHOTO: Dominic Lipinski / PA Wire / Press Association Images / Scanpix Growth was biggest for domestic violence – the police launched criminal proceedings in 3,607 cases that constitutes an increase of more than one-third – annual growth of 37 percent from 2,632 cases in 2017. At the same time, reports of domestic violence we...
Society
TALLINN - Ahead of the withdrawal of the United Kingdom from the European Union, tens of thousands of British citizens have chosen the citizenship of some other country, but only one Brit has recently chosen an Estonian citizenship. Spokespeople for the Ministry of the Interior told BNS that only one British citizen submitted an application for Estonian citizenship last year and the applicant was also granted the citizenship. Before that, no Brits had soug...
Society
TALLINN - Experts from Finland, Denmark, Norway and the Netherlands highlighted the importance of decentralization and granting local governments greater decision-making powers at a conference titled "Strong local government -- strong state?" in Tallinn on Wednesday.  All Nordic countries have chosen a model granting local governments significant decision-making powers, thus the central government does not prescribe how local governments are to fulfill the...
Society
The language learning application Drops by game developer Planb Labs, established in Estonia by Hungarian founders, was named Google Play's best app of 2018. With the number of downloads surpassing 10 million, Drops was named Google's app of the year as the revenue of Planb Labs, a company registered in Estonia, increased fivefold, CNBC said. The developer's revenue grew from €335,000 in 2017 to €1.7 million in 2018. The company's shareholders include Hung...
Society
TALLINN - The Estonian Health Board has banned the distribution of chlorine dioxide, also marketed as the Miracle Mineral Supplement (MMS), the A-component of an unused product, meaning the sodium chlorite solution, must be taken to a hazardous waste collection facility. Ester Opik, head of the Health Board's North regional department, said that the banning of the distribution of the product was caused by the fact that MMS, distributed as a cosmetics produ...
Society
Nature cannot abide a vacancy, as the saying goes. If just one year ago, Estonia was battling the sale of MMS and the practice of giving it to children, a new “miracle cure” called Advanced TRS has appeared on the market now. Even though the make-up of the substance is different, the promise to cure autism and cleanse the body of heavy metals, which kind of extreme detox is accompanied by severe side-effects, sounds all too familiar. TRS is recommended to...
Society
Allied NATO battalions will soon mark two years serving in the Baltics. They have worked better than expected but would need prepositioned heavy weaponry and a functional contingency plan in case of a crisis, a report by the International Center for Defense and Security (ICDS) finds. “We do not know how Russia would have acted had we not welcomed allies in Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania and Poland in 2017. I’m afraid they would have tested our resolve,” one of...
Society
The time of filing income tax returns is nearly upon us. The new income tax system, in effect since last year, will obligate many women who went on maternity leave toward the end of the year to make additional income tax payments, while those who give birth in the middle or at the beginning of the year have no such obligation. What this means is that some women will owe the state simply for giving birth “at the wrong time”. Laura Roop, who went on maternit...