EU still divided over curbing power subsidies with CO2 cap

A European Commission proposal to put an emissions limit on which power plants can be subsidised continues to divide the member states but the EU executive and the European Parliament stand united in supporting the CO2 cap.

As part of the Clean Energy Package, the Commission proposed putting a limit of 550g of CO2 per kilowatt hour on power plants, meaning the EU’s biggest polluters would be precluded from receiving public money under draft internal electricity market rules - according

This limit mirrors a similar policy implemented by the European Investment Bank (EIB), which has ceased funding any projects that exceed this carbon cap.

But it stops short of matching the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development’s (EBRD) ‘no coal’ mantra and has instead adopted a ‘technology neutral’ approach.

The Commission proposal predictably provoked a mixed response from the member states, some of which were displeased with the impact itwould have on coal-fired power generation.

Poland, which gets around 90% of its electricity from coal, came out against it but coal-lite countries like Estonia and Latvia supported the idea.

Germany and Finland backed the proposal in theory but have attached conditions to their support, including a requirement that so-called strategic reserves, power facilities for use during periods of very high demand but which are kept offline otherwise, are not included in the measure.

At an energy conference in Tallinn on Tuesday (19 September), the European Parliament’s rapporteur on the directive, Latvian MEP Krišjānis Kariņš (EPP), acknowledged the complex nature of the proposal, citing the bloc’s varying energy mixes.

His report on the Commission’s initial proposal has not amended the 550g criterion as a result and, following an upcoming vote in the industry committee (ITRE), it will be up to the member states to agree on a common position ahead of trilateral negotiations.

As holder of the rotating presidency of the Council of the EU, Estonia has been tasked with brokering a compromise within the Council of Ministers.

Its solution as it stands is to allow plants with higher emissions to operate a certain number of hours per year, instead of granting permanent exceptions or forcing plants to close.

The Commission originally proposed that the rules come into force for new plants from 2019, with full implementation for all facilities pencilled in for 2026.

In order to kick off the negotiations, Estonia on Wednesday (20 September) proposed extending this initial period from five to seven years, as well as qualifying that capacity mechanisms should be “temporary” and include storage and demand response.

Environmental and renewable energy associations already had concerns on the first point when theCommission initially presented it, as it means the biggest polluters will be able to keep emitting and receiving subsidies throughout the five-year transition period.

Reacting to Estonia’s efforts at a compromise, Dave Jones, a carbon analyst at Sandbag, a think tank, warned that it was “clearly a weakening of the Commission’s position on capacity payments” and insisted that it would be “crazy” to still be subsidising coal in the next decade.

The grace period afforded to polluters is also questionable, given that energy firms from 26 of the 28 member states, Greece and Poland excluded, signed an initiative in April pledging no new coal-fired plants in the EU after 2020.

At a press conference following theinformal meeting of energy ministers in the Estonian capital yesterday, Commission Vice-President Maroš Šefčovič indicated that he is hopeful the Council will be able to agree on its so-called general approach before the end of the year.

Commissioner Cañete used the Tallinn meeting and the energy conference that preceded it to reiterate his support for the 550g cap, insisting “capacity mechanisms will not be used as a backdoor subsidy of high-polluting fossil fuels”.

But the head of the European Parliament’s industry and energy committee (ITRE), MEP Jerzy Buzek (EPP), said at the same conference that internal electricity market policy, of which capacity mechanisms are very much a part, is not a tool for climate action.

He added that “that is what the Emissions Trading System is for” but acknowledged that there “is no conflict between the ETS and the 550g proposal.Consistency between measures is key to ensure the best deal for consumers.”

Clean energy groups pointed out that it makes no sense for two of the EU’s main policy areas to work against each other, as continued fossil fuel subsidies would inevitably limit the bloc’s chances of hitting its climate and emission reduction goals as part of the Paris Agreement.

Doubts about whether the ETS is fit for purpose also resurfaced in Tallinn, given the low carbon price, and NGOs have called for an ongoing reform of the scheme to ditch rules that allow low income countries to allocate free carbon allowances to electricity installations, amid accusations the funding has been used to modernise polluting fossil fuel industries.

Industry groups are also divided over the proposal. BusinessEurope labelled the 550g plan as a move “away from market-driven incentives”.

Research commissioned by the Polish Electricity Association (PKEE) also recently claimed that the Polish energy market would be unable to cope with the so-called EPS 550 requirement.

Its report insisted that it could lead to a loss of energy independence by dramatically increasing Poland’s gas imports, as well as lumping end consumers with an increased bill of nearly €240m between 2017 and 2040.

Member states have also claimed that EPS 550 breaches the treaties, as it forces national authorities to adopt a certain type of energy mix, which is a sole competence enjoyed by the member states. But Cañete insisted on Wednesday that “the proposal is perfectly in line with Article 194 of the TFEU.”


James Watson, Chief Executive Officer of SolarPowerEurope , said "Commissioner Arias Cañete was very clear yesterday in Tallinn: allowing public finances for the most emitting plants would be against any sort of climate or investment logic. Supporting a criterion of 550g CO2/kwh is about consistency with our Paris and Energy Union commitments. It is about common sense."

Pierre Tardieu, WindEurope Chief Policy Officer said : “WindEurope reiterates its original position. Capacity payments give undue compensation to redundant power plants that otherwise would have left the market. Consumers’ energy bills should not be supporting the continued operation of Europe’s most polluting power plants, when cleaner options to secure our power supply are available at low cost. We therefore continue to support efforts to promote the 550g CO2/kWh criterion for capacity mechanisms.”


Capacity mechanisms are measures taken by Member States to ensure that electricity supply can match demand in the medium and long term. Theyare designed to support investment to fill the expected capacity gap and ensure security of supply.

Typically, capacity mechanisms offer additional rewards to energy providers to keep plants on stand-by in case there is a shortfall in supply, on top of income obtained by selling electricity on the market.

The European Commission haswarned that such interventions could lead to the fragmentation of the planned single European market for electricityand launcheda “sector inquiry” intothose national support schemes,ledby Competition Commissioner Margrethe Vestager.An interim report issued in April 2015concluded that member states need to be “more thorough” in assessing whether such schemes are cost-effective or distort the market, and indeed whether they are necessary at all.

However, many member states have ignored the Commission's calls, and have pressed ahead with a variety of schemes to remunerate generators for keeping power plants on stand-by.

Rather than block such market interventions entirely, the Commission appears to have chosen to push for strict limits on capacity schemes, and ensure that they are open across national borders.

Read more news of Tallinn on the city site.
CO2 Estonia
If you notice an error, highlight the text you want and press Ctrl + Enter to report it to the editor
2 views in january
I recommend
No recommendations yet


Post your comment to communicate and discuss this article.

Even though education is a matter close to the heart of Estonia 200 leader Kristina Kallas, she cannot imagine herself fighting for the post of education minister: ideas can also be realized by someone else. You just took away Postimees’ editor-in-chief. In your opinion, how is the editorial to feel? Lauri [Hussar] had to give the matter thought, and I presume he did. We talked about why he wants to go into politics. Still, to what extent do you imagine wh...
TALLINN – Russia is seeking integration in Estonia only in words, Kalev Stoicescu, researcher at the International Center for Defense and Security (ICDS) who is running on the ticket of the Estonia 200 party in the March 3 general elections, said on Wednesday commenting on the words said on the subject by Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov.  "Russia is the only neighboring state which does not wish -- due to its own interests -- progress in integration...
Former top centrist Evelyn Sepp admitted that she donated money the origin of which was unknown to her to the Center Party in 2006. The former politician claimed other members also engaged in the practice but refused to name names. Sepp’s confession on ETV investigative journalism program «Pealtnägija» does not come as a total bombshell. She first said that such covert funding of parties is a widespread practice in the aftermath of the Silvergate scandal i...
"In addition to our ongoing programme of passenger vessel renovations, we are also continuing to upgrade and modernise our cargo vessels to ensure that we continue to develop this important part of our business," he noted, adding that the relocation of the company's Estonia-Finland cargo route to Muuga on the Estonian side in October 2017 and the launch of the Smart Port solution in Tallinn's Old City Harbour in spring 2018 both contributed to improved ser...
During the final week of 2018, a total of 2,524 patients with viral upper respiratory infections sought medical attention, 47.5% of whom were children. A total of 210 cases of influenza were laboratory confirmed, nearly twice as many as during the week before, according to Health Board data. Over the past two weeks, the number of flu cases has quadrupled. The majority of these cases were laboratory confirmed at emergency medical departments, from which pat...
I actually think that B1 is too low of a bar for attaining citizenship. You still can't participate in Estonian society on anything other than a superficial level as noted above, so I'm not sure how you can constitute a "citizen" on that basis. Naturally there has to be a high degree of arbitrariness, and that's precisely the point — whilst B1 level might be sufficient in German or French (I understand that it is the benchmark level when applying for citiz...
Following a white Christmas throughout most of Estonia, Wednesday will see sleet and even rain in parts of the country, and temperatures hovering around the freezing point will means slippery road conditions. Early Wednesday morning, many major highways were salted or wet, but some patches were still icy, the Estonian Road Administration said. Eastern parts of the country will see scattered rain or sleet. Temperatures throughout the day will remain around...
Last weekend, Christmas Eve as well as Christmas Day and Boxing Day still ahead means that most chemist's shops are closed for five days in a row. Tallinners can still get hold of prescription as well as over-the-counter drugs in the 5 Tõnismägi St and 19 Vikerlase St shops. As doctors' practices are closed for the holidays as well, people will have to turn to the emergency room of a nearby hospital in case of any more serious health problems. In Tallinn,...
Irene Ilves, the mother of former President Toomas Hendrik Ilves, died on Tuesday aged 91. Irene Ilves was born on 6 January 1927. An Estonian refugee, she raised her family in New Jersey, on the US East Coast. She is survived by two sons, Andres Eerik and Toomas Hendrik, and four grandchildren, Juulia Kristiine, Luukas Kristjan, Kadri Keiu and Hans Hendrik, Mr Ilves wrote on social media on Wednesday, adding that she will be very missed by family and frie...