Mandatory dividends plan seen as catering to a single family

Political competitors and entrepreneurs see the social democrats' mandatory dividends bill mainly as a present to the Kovalenko family that has been fighting for the rights of small shareholders of BLRT Group for years. The Kovalenkos refute claims.

Draft legislation the most prominent aim of which is to give small shareholders the right to demand payment of dividends recently merited the support of 22 MPs. According to the bill, such demands could only be countered with a 75-percent majority.

This would mean that a shareholder with 26 percent could effectively demand dividends in a situation where the majority would like to reinvest profits into expansion or maintain reserves.

MP Liisa Oviir, who introduced the bill, said that there have been situations in Estonia where majority shareholders have not only had an advantage buy where the rights of small shareholders have been severely limited.

For example, when shareholders have refused to pay dividends in a situation where it would make economic sense. Because the aim of small shareholders is to make a profit on their investment, denying them that right is neither fair nor good practice, Oviir found.

Almost all politicians and entrepreneurs who talked to Postimees said that the bill has been drafted mainly in the interests of the Kovalenko family that has been demanding dividends for shareholders in one of Estonia’s leading industrial companies BLRT Group.

The in-house conflict of BLRT has small shareholders Mihhail Gnidin, Valeri Kovalenko and Vladimir Toropov, represented by BLT Holding, on the one side and major owner Fjodor Berman and his relatives on the other. Both camps have been filing complaints against each other for years. BLRT has not been forced to pay dividends so far.

From small shareholder to majority owner

Member of the Riigikogu Legal Affairs Committee Valdo Randpere (Reform) referred to the bill as a dead cat the social democrats have been trying to drag over the committee's doorstep for some time. He said it is clearly the result of lobbying efforts by Valeri Kovalenko’s daughter, social democrat Anastassia Kovalenko, and the Estonian Small Shareholders Union.

«It all began when Anastassia Kovalenko started appearing alongside Rainer Vakra on pictures in Facebook. Next, she joined the party after which the desire to bring the small shareholders'topic to the committee intensified,»Randpere recalls. «The entire bill is pressure from the Kovalenkos and BLRT as they have found in Liisa Oviir someone to pursue it,» the politician said.

Randpere, who is fiercely opposed to the mandatory dividends idea, said that the Estonian business code works and does not need to be turned on its head. «If a small shareholder does not like where the company is headed, they can always sell their shares or buy more to be able to make decisions themselves,» he suggested.

Randpere said that the other cynical aim of the law is to collect more income tax on dividends. «We might as well tell companies we’re going to nationalize their profits on an annual basis. It is a hare-brained cast of mind in a free economy,»he concluded.

Member of the Riigikogu Finance Committee Aivar Sõerd (Reform) agrees and finds that the draft legislation is the initiative of a single family and company.

Sõerd said that while the bill might help a narrow group of small shareholders, it would be devastating for the Estonian economy.

The MP said that Estonian companies are very young on the European level and lack sufficient capital to be forced to pay dividends on an annual basis.

He gave the example of a situation where business climate takes a turn for the worse and the company would need to either invest or set aside reserves to remain competitive but cannot because 26 percent of owners are calling for dividends.

«It would destroy companies’ competitiveness, take away their ability to react quickly,» Sõerd added. He was convinced the bill would not pass. «Indrek Saar will become the new chairman of the Conservative People’s Party (EKRE) before this bill passes,»he said.

The bill is criticized by other parties as well. Legal affairs committee member Toomas Vitsut (Center) was also skeptical. He said that the state should exercise great caution in giving small shareholders gifts at the expense of major owners. «It might also scare away major investments,»he said.

Solutions not black and white

Anastassia Kovalenko refuted allegations and said she has never taken up the matter in Riigikogu committees. «I haven’t even seen that bill,»she said.

She was nevertheless glad the Riigikogu has taken the matter under advisement. She gave the examples of Sweden, Germany and Finland where the rights of small shareholders are better protected and criticized Estonia where the matter has never merited due attention from the legislation because «major shareholders are lobbying against it».

Kovalenko pointed to economic analyses that suggest people are more willing to invest and prepared to pay more for shares if the rights of small shareholders have legal backing.

«The situation in Estonia today is that if you have fewer than 51 percent of shares, you practically have no rights. The only thing that can help you is the major owner's manners and conscience,»she said.

The social democrat said that the mandatory dividends proposal needs to be weighed carefully and might not be the best solution. In her master’s thesis, Kovalenko proposes as one possible solution the obligation of major owners to buy out small shareholders if their rights have been misused over a longer period of time. The proposal has been included in the social democrats' bill.

Reacting to criticism from members of the Reform Party, Kovalenko said that there are always those who are against. She said that solutions are not black and white nor is it a matter of small shareholders making endless demands and giving orders. «There are preconditions to everything. Small shareholders would have to prove their rights have been misused and that repeated attempts to find a solution have failed due to opposition from the major owner,» she noted.

The bill was signed by individual MPs from the Social Democrat Party, Center Party, Free Party and the Conservative People’s Party.

news.postimees.ee
dividends BLRTGroup family
If you notice an error, highlight the text you want and press Ctrl + Enter to report it to the editor
4 views in january
I recommend
No recommendations yet

Comments

Post your comment to communicate and discuss this article.

Society
TALLINN – Russia is seeking integration in Estonia only in words, Kalev Stoicescu, researcher at the International Center for Defense and Security (ICDS) who is running on the ticket of the Estonia 200 party in the March 3 general elections, said on Wednesday commenting on the words said on the subject by Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov.  "Russia is the only neighboring state which does not wish -- due to its own interests -- progress in integration...
Politics
Former top centrist Evelyn Sepp admitted that she donated money the origin of which was unknown to her to the Center Party in 2006. The former politician claimed other members also engaged in the practice but refused to name names. Sepp’s confession on ETV investigative journalism program «Pealtnägija» does not come as a total bombshell. She first said that such covert funding of parties is a widespread practice in the aftermath of the Silvergate scandal i...
Society
"In addition to our ongoing programme of passenger vessel renovations, we are also continuing to upgrade and modernise our cargo vessels to ensure that we continue to develop this important part of our business," he noted, adding that the relocation of the company's Estonia-Finland cargo route to Muuga on the Estonian side in October 2017 and the launch of the Smart Port solution in Tallinn's Old City Harbour in spring 2018 both contributed to improved ser...
Society
During the final week of 2018, a total of 2,524 patients with viral upper respiratory infections sought medical attention, 47.5% of whom were children. A total of 210 cases of influenza were laboratory confirmed, nearly twice as many as during the week before, according to Health Board data. Over the past two weeks, the number of flu cases has quadrupled. The majority of these cases were laboratory confirmed at emergency medical departments, from which pat...
Society
I actually think that B1 is too low of a bar for attaining citizenship. You still can't participate in Estonian society on anything other than a superficial level as noted above, so I'm not sure how you can constitute a "citizen" on that basis. Naturally there has to be a high degree of arbitrariness, and that's precisely the point — whilst B1 level might be sufficient in German or French (I understand that it is the benchmark level when applying for citiz...
Society
Following a white Christmas throughout most of Estonia, Wednesday will see sleet and even rain in parts of the country, and temperatures hovering around the freezing point will means slippery road conditions. Early Wednesday morning, many major highways were salted or wet, but some patches were still icy, the Estonian Road Administration said. Eastern parts of the country will see scattered rain or sleet. Temperatures throughout the day will remain around...
Society
Last weekend, Christmas Eve as well as Christmas Day and Boxing Day still ahead means that most chemist's shops are closed for five days in a row. Tallinners can still get hold of prescription as well as over-the-counter drugs in the 5 Tõnismägi St and 19 Vikerlase St shops. As doctors' practices are closed for the holidays as well, people will have to turn to the emergency room of a nearby hospital in case of any more serious health problems. In Tallinn,...
Society
Irene Ilves, the mother of former President Toomas Hendrik Ilves, died on Tuesday aged 91. Irene Ilves was born on 6 January 1927. An Estonian refugee, she raised her family in New Jersey, on the US East Coast. She is survived by two sons, Andres Eerik and Toomas Hendrik, and four grandchildren, Juulia Kristiine, Luukas Kristjan, Kadri Keiu and Hans Hendrik, Mr Ilves wrote on social media on Wednesday, adding that she will be very missed by family and frie...
Society
Emergency services were called out on Wednesday morning after a man fell through ice at Lake Pühajärv, in South Estonia. The call was received by the Rescue Board at a little after 9.30, though by the time emergency personnel reached the scene, the man, who had walked on to the lake ice to go fishing, had extricated himself and reached dry land. The man stated that he had broken through the ice several times during his ordeal, after venturing about 50 m fr...